Exploring the Timeless Clash: ‘Inherit the Wind’ at Pasadena Playhouse Reshapes the Religion vs. Science Debate

Review: ‘Inherit the Wind’ at Pasadena Playhouse brings religion vs. science debate to our era

In a world where science and faith continue to clash, the Pasadena Playhouse brilliantly resurrects the timeless courtroom drama, "Inherit the Wind." This thought-provoking play by Jerome Lawrence and Robert E. Lee delves deep into the enduring conflict between religion and science, resonating with contemporary issues.

A Dated Play with Evergreen Themes


The year 1955 saw the birth of "Inherit the Wind," a narrative based on the 1925 Scopes ‘monkey’ trial in Tennessee. The story revolves around a public high school teacher who faces arrest for teaching Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution. The mere suggestion of humanity’s descent from apes sends shockwaves through the town’s devout power brokers, who vehemently oppose anything contradicting the Book of Genesis.

A Microcosm of America’s Divide

Political Polarization in the American Public | Pew Research Center

Set in Hillsboro, a quintessential small town in the heart of America, "Inherit the Wind" becomes a microcosm of the nation’s ideological division. With ignorant beliefs fueled by politicians seeking control, the play mirrors the present state of affairs where religion is exploited for political gain.

A Modern Makeover for Timely Relevance

The recent rendition of "Inherit the Wind" at Pasadena Playhouse, directed by Michael Michetti, maintains a respectful distance from historical accuracy. This artistic license allows the production to resonate with a contemporary audience. While the dialogue and characterizations may bear traces of their era, the theatrical presentation breathes new life into the play.

A Multicultural Cast

One striking feature of this production is its multicultural cast, a clear departure from the segregated 1925 Dayton, Tennessee. It reflects the changing face of America, emphasizing unity in diversity. The costumes designed by Sara Ryung Clement are unabashedly modern, with characters sporting distinctly contemporary clothing.

A Stripped-Down Presentation

Director Michetti opts for a stripped-down staging, accentuating the play’s psychological subtext. By doing so, he magnifies the play’s timeliness and emotional undercurrent that fuels the ongoing debate between religion and science.

The Core Conflict

The fundamental clash between religion and science reaches its dramatic zenith during courtroom confrontations. John Douglas Thompson’s portrayal of Matthew Harrison Brady, a fervent religious zealot, evokes a Shakespearean character. His impassioned rhetoric, delivered with a golden voice, resonates through its emotional fervor rather than textual meaning.

Alfred Molina’s Henry Drummond, the rational counterpoise to Brady, grounds the play in intellectual acumen. Drummond’s character recognizes the irrational facets of human nature, making him a defender of intellectual freedom, whether to believe or not.

The High Stakes

With high stakes in this battle, one might wish for more nuanced dramatic writing. The character of Hornbeck, a choral figure in the play, speaks with a cynicism reminiscent of old Hollywood reporters. Though Chris Perfetti breathes contemporary life into the character, new lines may have breathed fresh air into the character.

Rachel Hilson’s portrayal of Rachel Brown, who finds herself torn between love and loyalty, adds sharp poignancy to the story. Her struggles on the witness stand under Brady’s scrutiny exemplify the conflict’s emotional depth.

The Pasadena Playhouse’s rendition of "Inherit the Wind" rekindles the enduring debate of religion versus science, reminding us that this timeless issue continues to shape our era. The clash of beliefs and intellectual freedom remains as relevant today as it was in 1925.

With a multicultural cast and a modern makeover, this production offers a fresh perspective on the age-old argument, urging audiences to contemplate the ongoing struggle between faith and reason. "Inherit the Wind" at Pasadena Playhouse is a compelling testament to the enduring relevance of this classic narrative.

Whether you are a theater enthusiast or intrigued by the timeless battle between religion and science, this production at Pasadena Playhouse offers a riveting experience that will leave you pondering the age-old question: Can faith and science coexist harmoniously in our era?

Contemporary Relevance of the Religion vs. Science Debate

What is the central theme of ‘Inherit the Wind’ at Pasadena Playhouse?

Exploring Freedom of Thought

‘Inherit the Wind’ at Pasadena Playhouse prominently delves into the theme of freedom of thought. Mirroring the real-life Scopes trial, the play’s central character, Cates, faces arrest for violating the Butler Law, a regulation that forbids the teaching of evolutionary theory in Tennessee’s public schools. This legal battle symbolizes the censorship and limitations imposed on the realm of ideas and education, particularly in public school classrooms. The production powerfully underscores the importance of intellectual freedom and the enduring struggle to protect it in a world where ideology and science often clash.

What is the lesson of Inherit the Wind?

Championing Freedom of Thought

In ‘Inherit the Wind,’ the debate over evolution versus creationism serves as a backdrop, but the true essence of the conflict lies in humanity’s inherent right to free thought and free will. This extends beyond the specific issue at hand and encompasses any subject that challenges individual freedom. Written during the era of McCarthyism in the United States, the play resonates as a powerful reminder of the importance of safeguarding independent thinking in the face of ideological suppression.

What is Inherit the Wind about summary?

A Glimpse into the Scopes "Monkey" Trial

‘Inherit the Wind’ offers a fictionalized portrayal of the 1925 Scopes "Monkey" Trial, where John T. Scopes faced conviction for introducing Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution to a high school science class, in violation of a Tennessee state law. This thought-provoking play captures the essence of a pivotal historical event, framing it within a powerful narrative that continues to resonate with contemporary audiences.

Why is Inherit the Wind important?

A Powerful Metaphor Against Censorship and Thought Control

‘Inherit the Wind’ holds immense significance as it serves as a metaphorical response to the era of McCarthyism. While grounded in a historical event, the play goes beyond the 1925 Scopes trial, the Butler Law, and the creationism-evolutionism conflict. Lawrence and Lee use this narrative to underscore the broader themes of censorship and thought control, making it a timeless and compelling exploration of the consequences of suppressing free thought and ideas.

What are the conflicts in Inherit the Wind?

Reflecting American Society’s Diverse Conflicts

‘Inherit the Wind’ encapsulates a multitude of conflicts present within American society. It brilliantly portrays the ongoing battle between evolutionism and creationism, the clash of modernist views with fundamentalist beliefs, the separation of church and state, and the struggle between agnosticism and faith. These conflicts emerge from the inherent tension when differing beliefs and ideologies are not valued or respected, making the play a microcosm of the broader societal discord.

What is the main theme in Gone with the Wind?

Exploring a Tapestry of Themes

"Gone with the Wind" weaves a rich tapestry of themes that include the profound impact of war, the resilience and adaptation of characters, the dynamics of social class and status, shifting gender roles, and the complex issues of race and slavery. Beyond its captivating narrative, this literary classic is cherished for its historical significance, thought-provoking exploration of societal transformations, eloquent prose, ethical reflections, and its enduring legacy in the world of literature.

Show More

Related Articles

Back to top button