Exploring Gender and Identity: A Review of ‘People Collide’ by Isle McElroy

In the realm of literature, few narratives are as tantalizing as body-swapping tales. Isle McElroy’s "People Collide" dives headfirst into this fascinating literary territory, offering readers a thought-provoking exploration of gender, identity, and the unexpected twists that life can throw our way. In this article, we dissect McElroy’s sly body-swap novel, delving into its intriguing premise and the layers of meaning it unravels.

Unconventional Beginnings

Review: Isle McElroy

"People Collide" begins with a familiar fictional backdrop: a semi-dysfunctional marriage. Elizabeth, an up-and-coming American intellectual, accepts a prestigious teaching position in Bulgaria. At the core of her life is her marriage to Eli, an aspiring writer who often grapples with self-doubt.

Eli, our introspective protagonist, starts the narrative by contemplating his inadequacies. "I am not a responsible man. I am not a brave man," he admits. In a sudden burst of unusual bravery, he stumbles upon a dead cat in the road. What follows is nothing short of miraculous – the cat mysteriously springs back to life. But that’s just the beginning.

A Gender-Bending Twist

King Knight (Body Swap concepts) | Shovel Knight | Know Your Meme

Shortly after the bizarre cat incident, Eli realizes that he has swapped bodies with Elizabeth. In the eyes of everyone around them, Eli has become Elizabeth, and his wife has seemingly vanished. This surreal twist launches the story into uncharted territory, where the boundaries of identity, gender, and romance blur.

McElroy’s storytelling prowess shines as they skillfully navigate the complexities of this unexpected transformation. While Eli grapples with the initial shock, readers witness a profound shift in his perception of self. As he inhabits Elizabeth’s body, he discovers newfound sensations of sensuality and desire, experiences he never encountered in his own skin.

Queerness and Identity

Book review: Isle McElroy

As the narrative unfolds, "People Collide" invites readers to explore the deeper layers of Eli’s transformation. What initially seems like an absurdist metamorphosis takes on shades of closeted queerness and body dysphoria. Eli’s journey becomes a profound exploration of self-discovery and identity acceptance.

McElroy keeps the doors of possibility wide open, allowing readers to contemplate various metaphors and interpretations. Eli’s struggles with masculinity and his desire to be enigmatic find new dimensions as he becomes the Elizabeth he was meant to be.


"People Collide" by Isle McElroy is far from your typical body-swap story. It’s a literary journey that challenges conventional notions of gender, identity, and love. As readers delve into this sly and thought-provoking novel, they’ll find themselves questioning the very essence of who we are and how we define ourselves.

This book serves as a testament to the power of literature to provoke thought and spark conversations. McElroy’s storytelling takes readers on a rollercoaster ride of emotions and self-discovery. "People Collide" is a must-read for those seeking a fresh perspective on familiar themes.

Whether you’re drawn to tales of the unexpected or intrigued by the complexities of identity, "People Collide" promises to deliver a reading experience that will linger in your thoughts long after you’ve turned the final page.

So, if you’re in the mood for a unique literary journey, don’t miss out on "Review: Isle McElroy’s sly body-swap novel ‘People Collide’". It’s a novel that challenges the boundaries of storytelling and leaves you pondering the mysteries of existence.

Exploring Similar Themes in Literature

What is people collide by Isle McElroy?

People Collide by Isle McElroy is a captivating exploration of the classic body-swap trope. In this novel, McElroy takes a concept that has been a comic staple for decades and transforms it into a thought-provoking narrative. Unlike the humorous takes seen in shows like "Gilligan’s Island" and "Star Trek" or the comedy film "The Hot Chick," McElroy’s work delves into deeper themes. It challenges traditional notions of gender, identity, and self-discovery as a man and a woman find themselves in each other’s bodies. People Collide is a literary journey that invites readers to ponder the complexities of human existence and the boundaries that define us. Are you ready to explore this unique twist on a familiar trope?

Is ‘people collide’ a new conceit?

Is People Collide a new conceit? Absolutely. In this captivating novel by Isle McElroy, renowned for their previous work, The Atmospherians, we see the classic body-swap concept take on a fresh and thought-provoking dimension. While the trope traditionally delves into gender dynamics, McElroy’s narrative shifts the focus to an exploration of class. People Collide breathes new life into this familiar idea, offering readers a unique opportunity to engage with social and economic themes rather than simply gender roles.

Is ‘people collide’ a gimmick?

Is People Collide a gimmick? Indeed, Isle McElroy’s novel playfully embraces a gimmicky premise, skillfully exploring the concept of gender as a gimmick itself. The story kicks off with a classic setup—a semi-dysfunctional marriage—a familiar trope in literature. However, McElroy’s narrative takes this convention and turns it on its head, quite literally. In doing so, they challenge readers to reconsider the role of gender within the broader context of storytelling.

Is people collide a rom-com?

Is People Collide a rom-com? Indeed, it is. This novel by Isle McElroy proves to be a versatile and universally relatable book, with its title hinting at the serendipity of human relationships. It masterfully weaves elements of a romantic comedy, a genre that has evolved over time. The story emphasizes how life’s circumstances can unpredictably bring people together, reminding us that fate often takes the form of chance, even if we find the word "chance" a bit intimidating.

Show More

Related Articles

Back to top button